Loan Consolidation vs Refinancing

Are you confused about student loans and whether to consolidate or refinance them? It's common, but figuring out the difference is key to managing your college debt. This post breaks down consolidation and refinancing, helping you understand what each does and when one might be better for you.

Key takeaways

• Loan consolidation combines federal loans and keeps federal perks intact
• Refinancing can lower your interest rates but may strip away federal benefits
• Consolidation is a move for simplicity, not savings

Loan consolidation vs. refinancing

Loan consolidation combines your federal loans into one, making it easier to manage. Refinancing, on the other hand, swaps your current loans for a new one that might have a lower interest rate. Consolidation simplifies your payments but doesn't lower rates, while refinancing can save you money and adjust your loan terms.

How does student loan consolidation work?

Consolidating student loans is like organizing your money. It combines multiple federal loans into one, making it simpler with a single payment.

It's a smart move for organization, not necessarily to save money. You'll still pay the same total interest rate, but in just one payment instead of many.

• Combines many federal loans into one
• Keeps your federal loan benefits intact
• No interest rate reduction
• Could help you qualify for a government program

Although consolidation won’t reduce your interest rate, it can still lower your monthly payments. Depending on the repayment plan you choose when consolidating, you might be able to lengthen the term of your loan, spreading out the total cost of the loan over a longer period.

Bear in mind that a lower monthly payment can still result in higher total interest charges, since you’re making those payments for a longer time. Weighing these pros and cons is key to making a smart loan consolidation decision.

When should I consider federal consolidation?

Wondering when federal consolidation makes sense? Here are some situations where it’s a good idea:

• Got a bunch of federal loans causing stress? Consolidation can make it simpler.
• Interested in income-driven repayment plans? Direct loans are what you need, and consolidation can help with that.
• Want a change from your loan servicer? Consolidation might get you a new one.
• Want to reduce your monthly payments? Consolidation can make payments easier to manage by lengthening the term of your loan.

If your loans are already with the government and you like the perks they offer, consolidation could be a good fit for you.

How does student loan refinancing work?

It's time for a smart move. Consider refinancing your loans with a private lender. This means combining one or more loans into a new one, possibly with a lower interest rate.

This is a good option if you have private loans or if federal benefits aren't a priority for you. Take advantage of the opportunity!

• Merges private and federal loans into a private loan
• A path to potentially lower your rates
• Can save you money over the loan's life
• Trade federal perks for possibly better private terms

How does student loan refinancing benefit me?

Ready to see some real savings? Refinancing could reduce what you owe:

1. Lower interest rates mean less over the life of your loan.
2. You could reduce your monthly payments.
3. Option to transfer loan ownership, like taking on your parent's PLUS loans.
4. Refinancing can set your cosigner free from your loans.

TuitionHero Tip

Just remember, once you go private, you say goodbye to federal benefits like income-driven plans and loan forgiveness. So be careful.

When is refinancing the best option for me?

Wondering if refinancing is right for you? Here are some clear signs:

• Got a heavy private loan? Refinancing is a smart move.
• Looking to pay less overall? Check if you can get a lower interest rate through refinancing.
• Have a family member's loan in your name? Refinance to take control.

Simply put, if you're aiming for long-term savings and don't rely on federal safety nets, refinancing could be a great option for you.

How do I choose between the two?

Wondering how to decide between the two options? It's pretty straightforward:

• If you want federal benefits like forgiveness, go for consolidation.
• If you have a great credit score and steady income, think about refinancing—it could be good for your finances.

If you're unsure about losing your federal benefits, stick with consolidation. But if you're ready to save money and have your own safety net, refinancing might be the way to go.

And if student loans are confusing you, check out our guide on how to consolidate and refinance your student loans for more details. At TuitionHero, we're all about making complex things easy to understand.

Compare private student loans now

TuitionHero simplifies your student loan decision, with multiple top loans side-by-side.

[@portabletext/react] Unknown block type "component", specify a component for it in the `components.types` prop

[@portabletext/react] Unknown block type "component", specify a component for it in the `components.types` prop

Compare Rates

Dos and don'ts of choosing between loan consolidation and refinancing

Before you choose between loan consolidation and refinancing, it's important to know what to do and what to watch out for. The best decision depends on understanding your financial situation and what you want in the future.

Advantages and disadvantages of loan consolidation and refinancing

When you're thinking about combining and refinancing loans, it's helpful to look at the pros and cons. This way, you can figure out what works best for your money and education plans. Think about what each option can give you and what might not be so great, so you can make a smart choice about your student loans.

Advantages of loan consolidation and refinancing

• Simplification of monthly bill management
• Retention of federal loan benefits with consolidation
• Access to different repayment plans
• Potentially lower interest rates through refinancing

Disadvantages of loan consolidation and refinancing

• Consolidation can turn short-term loans into a longer payoff period, resulting in greater total interest charges.
• Refinancing federal loans means losing out on programs like income-driven repayment and Public Service Loan Forgiveness.
• Refinancing can also mean a hard credit check, which might be an issue if your credit isn't strong.
• Consolidation doesn't lower your interest rate — it just merges existing rates.

Why trust TuitionHero

At TuitionHero, we simplify college finances. We guide you through student loans, refinancing, and finding the best rates. Our advice also helps with scholarships, FAFSA, and credit card offers. Let's make financial decisions easier and more rewarding.

Frequently asked questions (FAQ)

Can consolidating my student loans help my credit score?

Consolidating your student loans by itself isn't a direct boost to your credit score, but it can lead to more consistent payments since you'll only have one monthly bill instead of several, possibly missing fewer payments. Consistency is key in maintaining a healthy credit score.

Is there a fee to consolidate my federal student loans?

Good news – there's no fee to consolidate your federal student loans through the Federal Student Aid website. Just watch out for companies that might offer to help you consolidate for a fee. These services are usually unnecessary. If costs and navigating financial aid have you scratching your head, check out our FAFSA help at TuitionHero.

Can I reconsolidate my loans if I’ve already consolidated?

Generally, once you've consolidated your federal student loans, you can't reconsolidate them unless you're adding a new unconsolidated loan to the mix. However, you can always refinance your consolidated loan with a private lender if you find a better rate and terms. Swing by TuitionHero to explore whether refinancing after consolidation is a smart move for you.

Final thoughts

Dealing with student loans doesn't have to be something you do alone. Whether you choose to combine or change your loan terms, the most important thing is to pick what works best for your financial situation.

If you're unsure, our team at TuitionHero is here to help and guide you—think of us as your money guide. For more tips on handling your student loans or to get started on understanding your finances better, check out the helpful resources we have for you at TuitionHero.

Source

• Student Loan Consolidation
• Federal Loan Consolidation
• Should I consolidate or refinance my student loans? | Consumer Financial Protection Bureau